Defence Renewal Annual Report 2014-2015 - Framework for Continuous Improvement

Alternate Formats

3. Performance Initiatives

At the core of the renewal effort is a portfolio of six performance-themed activities that are expected to generate the greatest opportunities for reinvestment into operational capabilities. In FY 2014/15, the Defence Team continued to assess, refine where necessary, and execute the original 22 performance initiatives. Additionally, two new initiatives were added to the portfolio: Ammunition Management (into Operations and Training) and enhancing the delivery of Emergency Communications and Dispatch Services by eliminating duplication of effort and adopting improved technology (into Management Systems).

In FY 2014/15, the Defence Team realised $84 million in reinvestment opportunities through a combination of cost avoidance and efficiencies – with cost avoidance understood as reduction of the anticipated need or cost for future resources, and efficiency meaning achieving the same output or effect with fewer resources.

And when added to last year’s reinvestment opportunities of $74 million, this represents a total of $158 million in reinvestment opportunities.

A summary of the six performance-themed activities follows.

Operations and Training. Director of Staff, Strategic Joint Staff (DOS SJS) continues to exercise oversight of these initiatives through the Operational Readiness and Training Committee; this governance has proven effective in terms of meeting regularly and addressing key strategic issues to maintain schedule. The four initiatives under this portfolio continue to mature over time producing both results and challenges:

  • 1.1 The CAF Operational Force Posture and Readiness (CAF FP&R) initiative has made significant progress. Key activities have resulted in a refined FP&R Directive containing a more informed Strategic Outlook and a focus on Reporting and Force Generation requirements. The FP&R framework and monitoring function was improved through the implementation of a new strategically managed readiness tool, and the development of a FP&R value model with associated performance metrics. Definitions and a set of rules to cost-capture the FP&R outputs have been established in collaboration with Level 1s, with definitions related to institutional and foundation training costs, as well as preparedness and sustainment of immediate or high readiness forces, constituting the backbone and boundaries of the FP&R cost capturing exercise. The work on aligning this initiative with the Programme Alignment Architecture is well under way and set for future success. The goal is to issue guidance in FY 2015/16, and then initiate the cost capturing process of FP&R tasks by FY 2016/17. Ultimately, the resource expenditure transparency that FP&R provides will reduce operational training inefficiencies and will facilitate the effective adjustment of expenditures to ensure that training aligns with evolving operational and policy priorities;
  • 1.2 Two of the objectives for the RCAF Simulation & Synthetic Environment initiative have met with moderate success: developing the capability for networking key RCAF, RCN and CA simulation assets; and, amending RCAF orders to strengthen simulation usage and implement senior advisory boards for simulation and training. The Weapons System Trainer project milestones for the CH-149, CC-177, and CC-150 have been adjusted to be more reflective of expected capital project approval timelines. Mindful of the fact that simulation is inherent in all three services and is a key joint forces enabler, further analysis suggests that embracing the broader DND/CAF Modelling and Simulation Roadmap could serve as a guide for expanding the scope and objectives of this initiative to the broader CAF Synthetic Environment. Key challenges will be the quantification of reinvestment opportunities in light of likely investment requirements -- and cost offsetting -- that result from modelling and simulation projects. However, in cooperation with the Chief of Force Development (CFD), discussions are underway to examine opportunities to leverage Defence Renewal for strategic objectives within the DND/CAF Modelling and Simulation Roadmap that have the potential to realise significant returns on investment through enhanced support to operational capability and readiness training across the CAF;
  • 1.3 The Maintenance Execution initiative has made significant progress and is working to mitigate the effects of the delay in awarding the contract to KPMG. The Defence Team -- supported by KPMG -- is developing a plan to perform maintenance more effectively and efficiently. Supported by KPMG’s initial on-site assessments of the 3rd Canadian Division in Edmonton, Fleet Maintenance Facility Cape Scott as well as select HMC Ships in Halifax, and at 14 Wing in Greenwood, the Defence Team continues to review potential reinvestment opportunities. The next phase will examine how to deliver local or service-level solutions across the environments that can be implemented quickly in FY 2015/16; and, identify where more strategic systemic improvements require senior leadership attention and potential investment; and,
  • 1.4 Ammunition Management was approved as a new Defence Renewal initiative in September 2014. A great deal of work was subsequently completed to identify interdependencies between this initiative and other Defence Renewal initiatives and the potential impact of wider Defence Team activities including the establishment of a Strategic J4. The SJS -- supported by KPMG -- continues work on this initiative. One of the key challenges associated with this initiative stems from its dependence on horizontal enablers such as Defence Renewal initiatives relating to Inventory Management, Warehousing and Distribution, and the Rationalisation of the Real Property Portfolio that are critical to its success. Level 1 stakeholders for these initiatives are working together to share metrics in order to ensure a cohesive and supportive development approach.

Maintenance and Materiel. This portfolio of four initiatives is well established, expertly managed and governed, and is progressing towards the achievement of its stated reinvestment opportunities. In FY 2014/15, the portfolio exceeded their forecast realising $54.8 million in reinvestment opportunities through cost avoidance and efficiencies:

  • 2.1 The Inventory Management initiative aims to avoid incurring the cost of unnecessary items by optimizing the amount of inventory procured and held. Renewal opportunities are measured across the National Procurement Corporate Account and are achieved by better enabling equipment management teams with business tools to more effectively plan procurement and thereby reduce overbuy expenditures. The initiative has declared $96.2 million in reduced overbuy expenditures since meeting its Deficit Reduction Action Plan (DRAP) commitment. The initiative is tracking towards the achievement of stated reinvestment opportunities and focuses on four key lines of operations/sub-projects:
    • the Distribution Resource Planning Project provides a business intelligence forecasting capability based on historical usage and Defence Resource Management Information System (DRMIS) data, has been fielded, and is in use across equipment teams;
    • the National Stocktaking Project, which complements existing departmental stocktaking activities to increase inventory accuracy and integrity, completed High Value/High Risk stocktaking as planned at 26 locations and verification visits at 14 locations (including the major depots);
    • the Inventory Management Modernization & Rationalization Project completed the first Disposal Modernization and Rationalization Study which will enable the initiation of dormant stock disposal and enhance data clarity in the system of record to facilitate procurement planning and contribute to reduced warehousing requirements; and,
    • the Automatic Identification Technology Project, which when implemented will enable sustainment of the efficiency gains achieved by the Inventory Management initiative, entered the Options Analysis Phase, confirmed project sponsorship and completed the initial draft of the Project Charter.
  • 2.2 The Warehousing and Distribution initiative progressed well in that there was an improvement in the oversight of the expenditure of designated funds in the Canadian Materiel Support Group transportation budget. The initiative still faces significant issues related to the limitations of DRMIS, and the use of business intelligence tools supporting the management of the supply chain. In FY 2014/15, the initiative was able to return $2.5 million in the third trimester, contributing to reinvestment opportunities and the offsetting of departmental financial pressures. Looking ahead, this initiative will continue to provide insights into how the Defence Enterprise is managing materiel as well as the potential to generate efficiencies -- and opportunities -- across the spectrum of Defence Renewal. It is also an enabler for other activities: in FY 2015/16, for example, we will identify and take action on dormant stock, and in conjunction with initiative 1.4 Ammunition Management, determine better forecasting techniques for ammunition holdings.
  • 2.3 The Maintenance Programme Design initiative consists of three distinct lines of activities -- Maintenance Program Rationalization; Sustainment Initiative; and Engineering Flight Test Rationalization:
    • Maintenance Programme Rationalization: aims to optimize maintenance programmes through in-depth analysis of the maintenance actions that are performed on selected fleets. An analysis on 15 different fleets has begun with initial results expected in FY 2015/2016. Additional opportunities will be prioritized to identify those with high-gain rationalization potential;
    • Sustainment Initiative: aims to institutionalize ways to optimize performance and value for money through the implementation of sustainment best practices that leverage the capabilities of the Government of Canada and Industry. This initiative has established strong joint governance with Public Works & Government Services Canada and Industry Canada. A set of ambitious goals for FY 2015/16 were established that include the advancement of four pilot projects. To be successful, the Sustainment Initiative requires close collaboration amongst several departments, industry support, and significant professional development and communications efforts; and,
    • Engineering Flight Test Rationalization: aims to reduce the cost of Engineering Flight Test delivery, and will analyze options from three primary focus areas: rationalization; outsourcing; and alternate location. As there is potential to outsource some current functions, industry is being engaged through a deliberate process. Once all related information has been compiled, potential courses of action will be developed and presented.
  • 2.4 Departmental Procurement remains the most significant initiative to achieve reinvestment in the Defence Renewal programme. In FY 2014/15, there was increased focus on leveraging Public Works and Government Services Canada’s (PWGSC) Acquisition Card Value Proposition Study that provides recommendations and options for optimizing and increasing acquisition card usage in government procurement. Significant effort has been directed towards identifying linkages to professional development requirements and the development of the procurement community of practice, as well as enhancing departmental efforts to increase procurement capacity and expertise. In order to be successful, however, this initiative relies heavily on achieving synchronization with concurrent PWGSC procurement reform initiatives, industry support to optimize procurement processes, as well as ability to "institutionalize" required changes and sustain momentum after Defence Renewal.

Information Management/Information Technology. The three initiatives within this series of initiatives continue to progress. Governance of these initiatives through the Information Management Board has proven challenging because of the largely de-centralized nature of the Defence IM/IT Programme. This will improve, however, through a robust implementation of the nascent Defence Chief Information Officer (CIO) model. Combined, the portfolio realised $4.8 million in reinvestment opportunities through efficiencies:

  • 3.1 The IT Service Management initiative benefited from an IRMC investment of $8.8 million in FY 2014/15, a key decision to ensure continued progress without impact on other high priority activities. The first of the two main deliverables of the IT Service Management initiative -- namely the implementation of a common enterprise-level IT Service Management toolset -- was completed in FY 2014/15. This new capability can now be leveraged to support the implementation of the second main deliverables of the IT Service Management initiative: the consolidation of more than 169 IT Service Delivery organizations into 22 or less IT Service Management Centres. To that end, the establishment of the first Regional Service Management Centre in Halifax (with the intention to consolidate 24 points of service in Atlantic Canada into a single help desk) was initiated in FY 2014/15. Work was also started on the development of a National Service Management Centre that will provide oversight to all of the IT Service Management Centres in DND/CAF. Very valuable lessons on the approach to consolidate the current IT Service Delivery organizations were learned during the development of the IT Service Management Centre in Halifax, including the dependency on the Inter-Capability Component Transfer (ICCT) process: the movement of responsibility from other Level 1s to the RCN has resulted in seven separate ICCTs to be managed. Chief of Programme (C Prog) has created an ICCT Process Review Working Group that has been tasked to review and modernise the ICCT process. Defence Renewal is actively contributing to the progress of this working group. The beginning of FY 2015/16 is expected to see improvements to the approach followed by the resumption of the consolidation effort which includes the establishment of a National Service Management Centre;
  • 3.2 The Application Portfolio Management initiative is near completion of the application inventory across the DND/CAF, the first and most critical step in establishing a complete data set. ADM(IM) is receiving active cooperation from across DND and CAF with 929 redundant or legacy applications decommissioned to date amounting to some $2.6 million in cost avoidance. This reduction of hundreds of applications across the enterprise reduces both portfolio complexity and stress against Network resources. Determination of the level of savings to be realized through this initiative is a significant part of the next analytical phase. The reinvestment potential will reflect a significant level of incentives to encourage continued cooperation and identification of future potential divestments by Level 1s; and,
  • 3.3 Rationalizing the Defence IM/IT Programme initiative has two main focus areas: IM/IT Programme level governance renewal and IM/IT procurement controls. There have been changes to timelines as more granular plans are developed. As well, coordination efforts with the Lean and Governance initiatives have -- and will -- continue to influence this initiative. ADM(IM) has developed a recommended Defence CIO Model and an IM/IT governance renewal plan to strategically align the Defence IM/IT Programme. The establishment of the Defence CIO Model and the execution of this plan will be shaped by DSX.

Infrastructure. The four initiatives under the Infrastructure Portfolio continue to mature, with each of the initiatives moving at a different rate. ADM(IE)’s oversight of these activities is exercised through the Infrastructure and Environment Board. The portfolio realised $11.4 million in reinvestment opportunities through cost avoidance and efficiencies:

  • 4.1 The Centralisation of Real Property Management initiative has accelerated its original schedule by transferring real property custodianship of RCN, RCAF and CA properties on the West Coast in Apr 2015 -- one year earlier than planned. Following achievement of Initial Operational Capability in April 2014 that resulted in reduction from nine to four Real Property custodians, the initiative remains on track for Full Operational Capability in 2016 when the Department will maintain a single Real Property custodian – ADM (IE). As well, DND has improved how minor construction projects (less than $1 million) are prioritized; by instituting a standardized approach to M&R planning, DND now has a more strategic view on environmental issues and liabilities at our bases and wings. This initiative is a key enabler of two other Infrastructure initiatives, those being to rationalize the real property portfolio and to optimize facilities management service delivery;
  • 4.2 The initiative to Rationalize the Real Property Portfolio continues to progress as infrastructure and its associated real property replacement cost is removed from the portfolio. With an additional IRMC investment of $12 million, 166 additional building demolition/disposals were completed in FY 2014/15 as was the strategic disposal of Jericho Beach in Vancouver, BC. For every dollar spent on demolition, we reduce the portfolio value by approximately $10 to $15, which in turn affects what we spend on payment in lieu of taxes as well as operations and maintenance. In actual terms, the $12 million invested in demolition last year resulted in a portfolio reduction of $120 - $180 million, meaning $3 - $4 million in annual cost avoidance being reinvested in the portfolio stemming from a forecast reduction in Operations, Maintenance and Repair, and a reduction in the amount Paid in Lieu of Taxes. The milestone for the approval of the 20 year rolling National Real Property Development Plan is rescheduled to late in 2015, but once it is approved, it will provide some initial momentum to strategically rationalize the portfolio. In the meantime, the various programmes within IE continue (strategic and routine disposals, demolition and consolidation, transfer and partnership and portfolio adjustments);
  • 4.3 The initiative to Optimize Facilities Management Service Delivery is ongoing. This initiative requires working with Defence Construction Canada and PWGSC, and looks at negotiating new and re-negotiating existing contracts to include bundling of contracts, reducing contract administration costs and levering volume of work. It should be noted that Procurement Services within IE is a new function and is in the process of structuring management data and benchmarks; and,
  • 4.4 The initiative to improve Real Property Project Delivery is focussing on using the integrated project delivery (IPD) process. The IPD process is a relatively new process in Canada; however, if project delivery time for multi-million dollar projects can be reduced by years, then there will be cost avoidance by not having to pay inflation on the years that are saved. In addition, since less time is spent on various approval stages, project staff will have more time to spend on other project activities, which could include other programme opportunities. A project to be used as a trial for proof of concept is in the selection stage.

Personnel. The five initiatives under this portfolio continue to mature and produce results while addressing challenges. The Military Personnel functional area is governed through the Canadian Armed Forces Personnel Management Committee (CFPMC). CFPMC has met regularly on a trimestral basis and due to other pressing strategic Military HR issues on the agenda, updates on the Defence Renewal initiatives have tended to be through secretarial review. DR Lead and Assistant Chief of Military Personnel (CMP) are working to improve the level of oversight of CFPMC to discuss Defence Renewal initiatives. Additionally, Defence Renewal Initiative 5.5 Cadets and Junior Canadian Ranger Renewal has been an inappropriate fit in the CFPMC structure; Chief Reserves and Cadets (C Res and Cadets) and DR Lead have been working to find a more appropriate oversight structure for this initiative. The portfolio realised approximately $12.9 million in reinvestment opportunities through cost avoidance and efficiencies:

  • 5.1 The Individual Training and Education initiative is making progress, but has been delayed in some areas due to important strategic NDHQ-level discussions on how to invest in continuous improvement. CMP/Canadian Defence Academy Staff provided a consolidated business case that helped inform the way-forward. This initiative will be managed as an activity with both Vote 1 and Vote 5 components, with funding support sought through the In Year Process, as required. Some discrete activities were advanced including: evolution of the Defence Learning Network; implementation of some enterprise programmes (including the Integrated Systems Approach to Training) to support Learning Management; the development of operational concepts appropriate to a modern learning architecture; and, the development of a CAF Mobile App Store. Additionally, there was implementation of WiFi capability in Borden, seen as the first instance of a planned pan-CAF wireless academic network. A Rationalized Training Delivery concept is currently being trialled;
  • 5.2 The modernization of the CAF Career Management Process continued with efforts that were realized during the last reporting period through the reduction of Temporary Duty costs for annual selection boards and the use of videoconferencing for Career Manager Interviews. The Canadian Forces Personnel Appraisal System refinements continued through FY 2014/15 including a simplification of the Personnel Evaluation Reports process: meaningful feedback is now provided to members in a manner that significantly reduces the work load on supervisors and review boards, and lessens the administrative burden at the unit level. Armed Forces Council provisionally endorsed the Leadership Development Model and associated novel concepts for Career Planning, Personnel Appraisal, Professional Development, and Competency Dictionaries. Additionally, one of the major outcomes of the Cost Move Corporate Account review was a new cost move model designed to improve the accuracy of cost estimates, which will greatly reduce annual financial fluctuations. Considerable effort is now being placed on the framework encompassing the Policy, Procedures and Practices Review, as well as on career and succession management;
  • 5.3 Military Personnel Management Capability Transformation (MPMCT) Project (GUARDIAN) is well-structured and supported to deliver its objectives and is aggressively following the project approval process. IM Group staff associated with the development team assigned to GUARDIAN were reprioritized by CMP to analyse and build a working interface for the Canadian Forces Recruiting Information System 2.0 (CFRIMS 2.0), the new recruiting software. As a result, implementation of GUARDIAN Release One has been re-assessed to occur in May 2016. The project continues to progress the definition of subsequent releases;
  • 5.4 The initiative to Modernize CAF Recruiting Process (CFRG 2016) has demonstrated significant progress with process improvements, notably with the creation of the Recruiting Operations Centre. A new centralized model sees the Recruiting Operations Centre performing the intake management that was previously conducted at 39 detachments across the country and allows every applicant to utilize e-applications. Applications to enrol in the CAF have doubled in the past year to 39,000, and 99.9% of all applications are done on-line: and the enrollment process that once took an average of 231 days to complete has been reduced by almost three months to an average of only 137 days. The recruiting and training synchronization process is ongoing, with the objective of better training alignment to reduce wait times. This portion should be completed in the Spring of 2016. The initiative’s modernization efforts provide more representative geographic coverage through e-applications, thus enabling quicker response times from recruiters to applicants, and improving synchronization in managing personnel awaiting training and recruiting Reserve Force personnel. The CMP decision to privilege an upgrade to CFRIMS 2.0 will greatly enable improved file management, overall recruiting effectiveness, and efficiency. The Social Media piece of CFRG 2016 is also progressing well and CFRG is now openly communicating on several networks including LinkedIn and Twitter, with others to follow. While intended to modernize the recruiting process through major process transformation, this initiative has also successfully enabled CFRG to meet increased recruiting requirements of the CAF Regular Force Strategic Intake Plan from 3600 to 3900 in FY 2014/15, and is well poised to meet additional requirement of 4200 for FY 2015/16; and,
  • 5.5 The Renewal of the Cadet and Junior Canadian Rangers (JCR) Programmes initiative is making steady progress including restructuring to adopt a centralized command and control model, reducing costs in full-time adult staffing, refocusing operating and maintenance budgets, and reprioritizing specific Cadet, JCR and Cadet Instructor Cadre training activities. As a result, there has already been reinvestment back into front-line Cadet programmes such as the provision of field training uniforms and increased fitness resources, while the Cadet population stands at 52,865 members (down 25 cadets from the FY 2012/13 baseline) and there are a total of 139 JCR Patrols (up +4 from the FY 2012/13 baseline). DR Lead will engage with Commander, National Cadet and Junior Canadian Rangers Support Group to determine a recovery strategy.

Management Systems. This portfolio is diverse with two different Level 1s leading the various initiatives. The oversight of Management Systems is executed by the Civilian Workforce Management Board (CWMB). This Board was originally set up to manage the Public Service targets for Strategic Review and DRAP and as these initiatives are closed out, the overall relevance of CWMB is being reviewed. Additionally, CWMB has met on an irregular basis due to a variety of issues. DR Lead will work with the VCDS and Assoc DM to examine alternatives for overseeing Defence Renewal Management Systems Initiatives going forward. Overall, the four initiatives within the portfolio continue to advance, albeit at different rates, and realised $0.2 million in reinvestment opportunities through cost avoidance:

  • 6.1 Lean Headquarters is a key initiative within the Defence Renewal portfolio and significant work has been performed by several organisations including C Prog and CFD to define and clarify the extent and nature of National or HQ level support. Working with KPMG, the Lean HQ Team has now completed a preliminary departmental overview of NDHQ National level support organisations -- Lean HQ will provide clear recommendations on the structure and size of a variety of Level1s based on a holistic examination of their various functions and the most effective manner through which those functions may be delivered. Going forward, this enterprise-level view will inform ongoing detailed analysis of three candidate organisations in pilot studies: CMP, ADM(Mat) and ADM(IM), which combined, represent 65% of NDHQ Full Time Equivalents (FTEs) to produce macro design options followed by micro designs and plans to implement new structures as appropriate;
  • 6.2 The Project Approval Process Review (PAPR) has completed a detailed study of procurement to meet their mandate of twice the project approval throughput in half the time. A new protocol for a less time-consuming way ahead was negotiated with the Treasury Board Secretariat to streamline less complex projects within MND authority, and a phased implementation strategy is being staffed. The PAPR recommendation for a prioritized list of projects proportional to Departmental capacity has resulted in the Capital Investment Programme Plan Review (CIPPR) and a computer simulation has been developed that can be used to assess the impact of future changes to the approval process. Further development of this important enabling initiative will proceed and has been identified as an opportunity for investment through the use of a Defence Renewal optional services contract with KPMG. C Prog and the DRT will need to determine an updated forecast and schedule;
  • 6.3 The review of Civilian HR Management is progressing well towards HR planning, programmes and operational service delivery aligned to better support the Defence Team. This goal will be achieved by: having internal business processes and roles clearly defined and communicated; improved self-service capabilities; standardization of work processes, and; smarter use of qualified resources. The DRT will work with ADM(HR Civ) to determine follow-on renewal opportunities in the functional management of DND Public Servants; and,
  • 6.4 Consolidation of Emergency Dispatch was launched as a new DR initiative in September 2014 and is progressing with the agreement of both the CF Provost Marshal and ADM (IE)/CF Fire Marshal. This initiative will also conduct a detailed examination of emergency communications equipment within the CAF with a view to ensuring that our communications equipment is interoperable with other emergency services in Canada. In order to accelerate progress, this initiative is being supported by a Defence Renewal optional services contract with KPMG to further develop the initiative’s plan and scope.

It is important to note that the Defence Renewal Charter is clear:

The portfolio is not static. As analysis is refined and implementation unfolds, the reinvestment opportunity associated with the initiatives will evolve – some will surely run into roadblocks and will need to be refined, while others will yield greater opportunities than expected….

Over the course of FY 2014/15, the DRT led a substantial effort to work with Level 1s to develop and deliver an updated reinvestment profile to the IRMC in November 2014. They noted that a recurring reinvestment opportunity represented by the 24 performance initiatives of $700-1050 million is possible by FY 2019/20 compared to the original opportunity assessment of $750-1200 million by FY 2017/18. The delay in the award of the Change Management Services contract with its focus on two major initiatives (Maintenance Execution and Lean Headquarters) as well as adjustments to the following two performance initiatives, are the primary causes for the revision:

  • Rationalization the Real Property Portfolio (initiative 4.2) was originally assessed as an opportunity for $69-127 million in effectiveness, avoidance and efficiency by 2018. More detailed analysis has determined that this profile extends to 2035. Continued IRMC investment in disposals should assist in recovering some of the schedule; and,
  • Project Approval Process Review (initiative 6.2) was originally assessed as an opportunity for $90-110 million in cost avoidance by 2018. Reviews of the initial modelling and simulation analysis, and other efficiencies such as the Defence Procurement Strategy and Shared Services Canada, have put this schedule at risk.

The FTE opportunity within the overall forecast is currently projected to be 2400-4100 FTEs compared to the original estimate of 2800-4800 FTEs. The primary difference is due to the removal of the Maintenance and Materiel FTEs from the overall total pending further analysis of the Warehousing and Distribution, and the Maintenance Programme Design initiatives. The FTE opportunity of these two initiatives will become evident as they progress in the near future. Two initiatives, Lean HQ and Maintenance Execution slipped their forecast by 18 months due to delays in awarding the work to KPMG.

These are achievable targets -- targets that were set by defence -- but they will require a determined effort by all members of the Defence Team: civilians and military alike.